In partnership with
Retirement Download
Strategies for a successful retirement
Managing Sequence-of-Returns Risk in Early Retirement
Early market losses can do outsized damage when you live on your portfolio. Use a clear guardrails framework to set a starting withdrawal rate, adjust with the markets, and protect your first decade.
What sequence-of-returns risk is
Two retirees can earn the same average return and end up in different places. If poor returns arrive early, withdrawals lock in losses and leave fewer dollars to rebound later. Vanguard flags this “sequence” timing as a key threat when retirement begins near a bear market.
Think of it as path risk. The order of returns, not just the average, drives how long your portfolio can support spending. Planning specifically for the early years reduces this vulnerability.
Why the first decade matters most
When markets drop early, you must sell more shares to fund the same spending, which shrinks the base that can recover. Guardrails research and planner guidance highlight higher failure risk when rough returns cluster at the start of retirement.
Your goal is to keep early drawdowns from compounding. Small trims in down years plus funding order choices can make a meaningful difference over 25 to 30 years.
A guardrails framework you can live with
Guardrails give you preset rules for when to take a raise and when to take a trim. The classic version is the Guyton-Klinger rule set. Many advisors also use probability bands from a Monte Carlo plan to trigger raises and trims when success odds move outside a chosen range. Both aim to keep spending sustainable without guessing each year.
Picking a starting withdrawal rate
Your starting rate anchors everything. Morningstar’s 2025 work pegs about 3.7% as a baseline safe starting percentage for a 30-year plan, with the exact figure depending on asset mix and assumptions. Treat it as a launch point, then let your guardrails adjust.
Learn from this investor’s $100m mistake
In 2010, a Grammy-winning artist passed on investing $200K in an emerging real estate disruptor. That stake could be worth $100+ million today.
One year later, another real estate disruptor, Zillow, went public. This time, everyday investors had regrets, missing pre-IPO gains.
Now, a new real estate innovator, Pacaso – founded by a former Zillow exec – is disrupting a $1.3T market. And unlike the others, you can invest in Pacaso as a private company.
Pacaso’s co-ownership model has generated $1B+ in luxury home sales and service fees, earned $110M+ in gross profits to date, and received backing from the same VCs behind Uber, Venmo, and eBay. They even reserved the Nasdaq ticker PCSO.
Paid advertisement for Pacaso’s Regulation A offering. Read the offering circular at invest.pacaso.com. Reserving a ticker symbol is not a guarantee that the company will go public. Listing on the NASDAQ is subject to approvals.
How to set the knobs
Write your rules on one page. First, choose your bands. A simple choice is plus or minus 20 percent around your starting rate. Next, choose a change size. Many retirees use a 10 percent raise or trim to the dollar withdrawal when a band is crossed. If you prefer probability bands, define your success range and tie raises and trims to high and low thresholds.
Calibrate with a second set of eyes (Partner)
Guardrails work best when taxes, Social Security timing, and required minimum distributions (RMDs, the minimum amounts the IRS requires you to withdraw each year from most retirement accounts starting at a set age) all pull in the same direction. If you want help pressure-testing your bands and funding order, try the Money Pickle quiz to match with a vetted advisor. The goal is simple: align your withdrawal rules with your tax plan so your spending feels sturdy in rough markets.
Ask the advisor for a one-page policy that lists your starting rate, bands, change size, and which accounts to tap after down years. When you are ready, here is a direct CTA: Take the Money Pickle quiz now.
Build your protection layers
Use a few simple layers so you are not relying on only one lever.
Cash or short-bond buffer. A near-term reserve reduces the chance you will sell stocks in a slump. Schwab outlines bucket approaches and withdrawal sequencing that lean on cash, CDs, and short bonds for near-term spending.
Sequence-aware funding order. After a bad equity year, draw more from cash or bonds, then refill during recoveries. Schwab’s order of withdrawals starts with RMDs, then income, then maturing bonds and CDs before selling other assets.
Right-sized equity mix. Keep enough stocks for growth without forcing deep cuts in a downturn. Vanguard and Schwab emphasize balancing growth potential with the need for near-term liquidity.
Social Security can also reduce portfolio strain. Delaying benefits increases the payment with delayed retirement credits until age 70. There is no increase after age 70.
What this means for you
Your first 10 years deserve extra padding. Pair a starter rate with a cash and bond buffer so you are not selling stocks at bad prices.
Flex beats fixed. Guardrails help you spend more in good runs and pull back just enough in bad ones to protect the plan.
Write it down. A one-page policy turns scary markets into small, preplanned tweaks.
Consider this
Pick your starting rate for the next 12 months. That is the percent you will withdraw in year one. Example: 3.8% of $1,000,000 = $38,000.
Set your guardrails. Choose your bands and a change size for your dollar withdrawal if a band is crossed. Example: with a 3.8% start, bands at ±20% are 3.0% and 4.6%; a 10% change size means $3,800 up or down from $38,000.
Fund a 12–36 month cash and short-bond buffer and note when you will refill it. You can hold this at Schwab Brokerage. Example: 24 months of a $38,000 withdrawal needs about $76,000; refill after good market years.
How was today's newsletter?
👩🏽⚖️ Legal Stuff
Nothing in this newsletter is financial advice. Always do your own research and think for yourself.